What I don't understand is why some are focusing on the PFD.
I could be mistaken but don't recall it being said we had to remove statements about PFDs being required by law.

But I believe statements where made that said PFDs would be required for all paddlers at all times within the club - which means any tuilik wearing paddlers could not practice their skills and still be club members.

Just like there's no sense in wearing a helmet on a mill pond - there are places where a PFD isn't necessary when a Tuilik matches the activities better. It's about understanding what activities your engaging in, reading the conditions and assessing one's abilities.

The main advantage a kayak has over other watercraft is it's ability to recover almost instantly from a capsize - yet we're not making rolling a requirement. If I had to pick I'd rather three strong rolls (including the hand roll should the paddle have been lost) than to focus on my PFD to save my butt.

Your welcome to try out my tuilik anytime - you might be surprised.